Hoka Clifton 9 GTX Review

The Clifton 9 is Hoka’s most popular neutral, cushioned running shoe and has been part of Hoka’s road running range for over 14 years. Northern Runner has already reviewed the Hoka Clifton 9 with the ‘standard’ mesh upper here. The Hoka Clifton 9 GTX is in effect the same shoe with a waterproof upper. However, having run in the Clifton 9 GTX for a few hundred miles now I have found that they are a bit different and decided that the Hoka Clifton 9 GTX warrant’s its own review, to explain the difference in fit and feel.

The upper of the Clifton 9 GTX is made using Gore-Tex Invisible Fit. Previously, waterproof shoes used to have a liner stuck to the inside of the upper material to make them waterproof. This took up some of the space inside the shoes, meaning that waterproof shoes would be a snugger fit than the mesh upper equivalent. Two layers of material in the upper made them less breathable and warmer feeling, especially in spring/summer. This type of waterproof upper is also stiffer and doesn’t mould to the shape of your foot as nicely as a thinner upper.

Gore-Tex Invisible Fit is in essence where the Gore-Tex material is used to ‘make’ the upper, it’s not added to it. There is just one piece of material. This means that the mesh version of the running shoe has a similar fit to the waterproof version. It also means that the upper is more flexible, so it moulds to your foot shape better and the upper breathes better than the previous method of putting Gore-Tex into shoes.

The material used to make the upper of the Clifton 9 GTX is thicker than the mesh upper of the Clifton 9. It has to perform even in the coldest months and is capable of keeping your feet warm and protecting them from the wind, rain or snow.

The sizing is the same, as despite the extra thickness, it doesn’t really take up any noticeable volume. What is different is the ‘feel’. I am naturally more aware of the GTX upper, as it is a more durable, less light & airy material than the the standard Hoka Clifton 9. The trade off for the high level of protection is a little more snug & enclosed feel, with a bit less toe spread and function.

The tongue is gusseted, as you would expect in a shoe with a waterproof upper. If you stand in a puddle (that doesn’t go over the top of the gusset) you are more likely to keep your feet dry. The drawback to this is that the folds in the gusset take up a bit of room and prevent the top of the upper from forming to your foot shape as well as they do in the standard Clifton 9. I felt it initially when clocking up some review miles, but after a few runs the upper took the shape of my foot and now the shoes fit as securely and comfortably as the mesh Clifton 9.

The Clifton 9 GTX also feels a little stiffer and firmer to run in because of the Hoka ‘traction pods’. The pattern on the pods has been changed to give the outsole more grip. It does the job in my experience, especially on wet tarmac and greasy moss-covered paths. You trade off a little bit of ‘smoothness’ but get extra grip in the wet.

The heel cup is shaped like a swallow tail like the Clifton 9 but, not quite to the same extent. The heel tab is still moved away from the Achilles which prevents any potential rubbing and makes the heel cup a bit springier so that it grips the heel better. By not sticking out quite as much it won’t funnel water into the shoes.

As the Clifton 9 GTX is designed to be used during the worst of the winter when you are likely to be running when it’s dark, there are reflective tabs on the upper.

Feel the Cold In Your Feet?

Although Gore’s Invisible Fit uppers are breathable, they obviously aren’t as breathable as a mesh upper. For this reason we would suggest that the Clifton 9 GTX is best used when it gets colder. Expect to get a bit warm and sweaty too much before winter. When running in temperatures below 5 degrees I find that my socks aren’t damp and this kind of waterproof running shoe feels snug, warm and comfortable. You really notice the advantage of shoes with a weatherproof upper on cold windy days, as the wind doesn’t pass through the shoes and make your feet cold. You do have to be a bit careful with the legwear. In heavy rain the water can run down your legs and into the shoes, with nowhere to go and leaving you sloshing around!

A tip to keeping shoes waterproof is to clean off any grit or sand from the upper regularly. It can act like sandpaper and over a period of time reduce the effectiveness of the waterproofing.

In summary the Hoka Clifton 9 GTX is a great everyday training shoe for colder windy days and the winter months, where you want to remove excuses and get running. It’s not a racing shoe, it’s all about comfortable runs, whether you’re new or a veteran that likes that extra bit of protection. A great option if you feel the cold like me.

Alternatives to Clifton 9 GTX

Clifton 9 GTX vs. Brooks Ghost GTX: The Brooks Ghost 15 GTX also have a Gore Invisible Fit upper. The difference between the Ghost 15 GTX and the Clifton 9 GTX is not the waterproofing but, the difference in the fit, feel and ride of the shoes. The Brooks Ghost has a higher heel to forefoot drop and is designed more for the heel striker. The Clifton 9 GTX has a softer feel to he cushioning and a rocker: https://www.northernrunner.com/blog/brooks-ghost-15-review/

Comments are closed here.