Altra Experience Wild 3+ Gore-Tex Review
Now that autumn has officially decided to start this year and the rains have fallen, I was very keen to test the latest Altra Experience Wild 3+ Gore-Tex. I enjoy a wild run as much as the next person, and I appreciate that getting wet feet is a necessary hazard if you want to enjoy the off-road and what it has to offer, all year round. The Altra Experience Wild 3+ shoes are a favourite and see me comfortably over grass, forest paths, rocky trails and most other surfaces with ease: super comfy, great grip and stable on uneven surfaces. In anticipation of the frosty, dew-covered grass and expected puddles, I couldn’t wait to try the Gore-Tex models on. Happy feet? Absolutely!
Despite the Gore-Tex upper usually being restrictive in volume on some trail shoes (and I have wide feet), my feet fit perfectly. The Altra Standard FootShape toe box is as comfortable and roomy as ever. I’d say this is an important feature for me: trail running with squashed feet leads to rolled ankles, in my experience. Having space for your toes to sit and function as nature intended makes for a much more grounded and therefore stable running experience. Let’s face it, having more contact with the ground, surface-wise, helps keep you grounded (and upright!), or at least that’s what I find. Also, as with any Gore-Tex shoe, they keep your feet warmer than non-Gore-Tex shoes (not really a problem, as you’re wearing them in cooler temperatures of 10°C or less), so having room if your feet expand a little stops them feeling pinched.
The shoe is essentially the same as the Altra Experience Wild 3+: a 4mm drop from heel to forefoot, gentle enough to encourage your feet along and giving the shoes a nimble feel. A very subtle rocker geometry adds to the agility of the shoe. Great for hopping over gnarly tree roots and cobbly paths. The midsole is 32mm at the heel and 28mm at the forefoot, so mid-level cushioning which does feel soft and flexible underfoot; again, exactly what you want from a trail shoe. The midsole is Altra’s EGO P35 foam, which is responsive and durable as well as super comfy.
But here is where the two shoes really differ for me, apart, obviously, from the waterproofing! The midsole on step-in was what I expected: soft and a little springy. However, when you’re out on the trails, the overall feel of the shoe changes due to the Gore-Tex upper, becoming much firmer and less flexible than its sister shoe, the Experience Wild 3+. A problem? Not really. That firmer feel helps protect my feet from harsher obstacles underfoot. Less flexibility? It was a bit strange to begin with, as the non-Gore-Tex 3+ is so flexible that it really fits like a second skin. I noticed the reduced flexibility initially (and you’ll see this if you try to flex the shoe before you put it on), but after an hour or so, the shoes started to flex with my feet. They also have torsional flex, so when you’re covering rough ground, they will flex with your foot to accommodate the lumps and bumps. Worth it? …100%!
The shoe is incredibly light, approximately 323g for men’s and 269g for women’s. You can dance along the trails agilely and with confidence. The Vibram Megagrip rubber outsole with 4mm traction lugs offers excellent grip even when surfaces get a bit sloppy. The Gore-Tex upper is comfortable and doesn’t ridge or rub when it bends over the ball of your foot (which can be a problem with some other Gore-Tex shoes). The waterproofing is created by integrating GORE-TEX Invisible Fit directly into the mesh material. It isn’t stiff or bulky, but these extra protective layers restrict natural flex compared to the soft, engineered mesh of the standard model. When bonded to the midsole, this contributes to the firmer, less flexible initial feel I noticed earlier. The tongue is gusseted with a thinner Gore-Tex material, so unless you’re diving in head first, your feet will remain relatively dry. I say relatively, as Gore-Tex can keep the water out, but your feet, naturally, will perspire as they work, so socks may feel slightly damp, but not through any failing of the shoe!
As you’d expect, Altra have thought this shoe through. A handy heel pull tab means you can slip in and out of the shoe without getting covered in mud. The Velcro tab at the bottom of the heel ensures you can attach a gaiter if you’re covering rougher, gorse- or heather-covered ground, where, inevitably, the undergrowth will try and work its way into your shoe via your socks! Even the laces are a bit coarser in texture, which means they don’t work their way undone as you run. This is my only bugbear with the Altra Experience Wild 3+, where the laces feel super silky, but I do have to retie them during long runs!
So, would I choose the Gore-Tex version over my much-loved Experience Wild 3+? For the colder, wetter months, absolutely! You still get that lovely roomy toe box, plenty of grip and the nimble feel that makes the standard version such fun to run in. Yes, the Gore-Tex upper makes the shoe feel a little firmer and less flexible initially, but for me, that’s a small price to pay for warmer, drier feet when the trails are wet and the grass is covered in frost. If your runs take you across muddy fields, forest paths and rocky trails, and you don’t fancy starting every run with soggy socks, these could be a great winter companion. Happy feet, happy trails!
Alternatives to Altra Experience Wild 3+ Gore-Tex
Topo Ultraventure 5 GTX
The Topo Ultraventure 5 GTX has the same roomy toe box as the Altra Experience Wild 3+ Gore-Tex, anatomically shaped to allow for foot function and space for the forefoot. So, if you have wider feet, or simply enjoy the freedom that gives your toes, then the Topo Ultraventure 5 GTX is a good option for a road-to-trail shoe. The upper might feel slightly more rigid on first step-in, but it does adjust to the foot without creating pressure points that could irritate over longer runs. The Topo Ultraventure is a well-cushioned shoe with a less flexible midsole than the Experience Wild 3+, so moving to the GTX version, there was no noticeable change in the ride compared with the non-GTX version. The main point of difference is the feel of the fit generally. The Altra Experience Wild 3+ fits like a glove and is incredibly light and nimble, whereas the Topo Ultraventure has a sturdier fit and feels more robust when taking on hard-packed tracks and trails. The 5mm drop helps you roll along comfortably on less technical ground, and you’ll appreciate the cushioning all day. But if you want to breeze through the trees, the Altra Experience Wild 3+ GTX is better equipped. Read our review: Topo Ultraventure 5 Gore-Tex Review.
Brooks Cascadia Gore-Tex
The Brooks Cascadia 20 GTX is a waterproof trail running shoe designed to be versatile enough to be used to run to your trail or for running routes that have a mix of road and trail. The cushioning level and length of the lugs make it more suited to hard-packed trails. It does offer some traction on softer ground, but wouldn’t be considered a good choice for routes with very soft, deep mud. Has a 6mm drop and a higher stack height than the Altra Experience Wild GTX, so will feel more cushioned. The lugs are similar in length, so will be just as effective on uneven ground. Width fittings so if you like the room of an Altra, you can fit comfortably into a women’s D width, or men’s 2E, or 4E (extra wide). Read our review: Brooks Cascadia Gore-Tex Review
Hoka Speedgoat 7 Gore-Tex
The Hoka Speedgoat is a trail running shoe designed to perform well across a wide range of terrain and distances, from a short morning run by the river to a 100-mile ultra. The ride is responsive and suits runners who like the feel of a quicker shoe. Differs in philosophy to Altra’s natural foot function, has a rocker to propel you along, and a higher stack, so the ride is softer. The drop is only slightly higher at 5mm, so the feel is stable for uneven ground. A narrower toe box may not suit you, if you enjoy the natural FootShape that Altra provide. Find them here: Hoka Speedgoat 7 Gore-Tex
Hoka Challenger 8 GTX
The Hoka Challenger 8 GTX is a waterproof trail running shoe designed for hard-packed tracks and trails, and it also performs well on road-to-trail routes. With a balance of cushioning and traction, it’s a solid all-terrain option. The shape of the shoe is traditionally narrower at the toe box, so if you have slim feet, or feel the Altra FootShape is too broad, these may feel snugger. The Challenger 8 GTX has a much higher drop at 8mm, high for a trail shoe, but this doesn’t make it feel unstable. Like other Hoka shoes, your foot sits within the midsole rather than on top of it. The shoe is designed to work like a mountain bike tyre, absorbing the impact of uneven surfaces and contouring to the trail. Despite the high stack, the cushioning still allows some awareness of the ground, and your shoes will be working as hard as you do! If your trails are hard-packed and less technical, the Challenger 8 GTX will glide you along gracefully. For tracks where nimbleness is needed, the Experience Wild 3+ GTX may be a better bet. Find them here: Hoka Challenger 8 GTX
Normal Cadi Gore-Tex
The Normal Cadí GORE-TEX® is a cushioned trail running shoe designed for long runs, everyday training and smoother trail terrain in changing weather conditions. Building on the versatile Cadí platform, the GORE-TEX® version adds waterproof protection while retaining the soft cushioning, stable feel and smooth ride that make the shoe well suited to covering longer distances. Its lightweight midsole provides soft, stable cushioning, with a 35mm heel and 29mm forefoot stack creating a 6mm heel-to-toe drop. Find them here: Normal Cadi Gore-Tex
Comments are closed here.